“We have been eating at Mama Lisa since 2003. In all those years of eating at Mama Lisa, whether it’s been for lunch or dinner we have never been disappointed. We are Italian and when we go out to eat Italian food we look for a place that can satisfy our taste buds. …“
- Feb 13, 2009
“I grew up going to these guys dad and uncle’s restaurant, the old Umberto’s of Patchogue. Its like the same place as far as the food, which is some of the best around, including the pizza. Umberto’s use to be standing room only on weekends and was known island wide. …“
- Nov 21, 2010
“In an area saturated with pizza parlors and Italian restaurants this place stands out in the crowd. The pizza is very good and the Italian dinners are outstanding.”
- Feb 15, 2010
joe ? - Mar 28, 2011
The freshest ingredients!
Liked: Food, Service, Atmosphere, Value
lead997 ? - Feb 28, 2008Best Pizza on Long Island Truly one of the best pizza places on Long Island. I am so happy to find a fabulous pizza place in Mastic.
Adam ? - Feb 24, 2008pizzaguru Highest caliber pizza in the area. Top notch ingredients. Out of the dozen or so other comparable operations in the area, Mama Lisa steps up the quality, consistency, and atmosphere. If your in the Mastic-Shirley area and have your Italian craving make sure to check out this little gem.